Title: IME Records Review Worked Example: a 640-Page Lumbar File
URL: https://imerecordsreview.com/worked-example/

> A synthetic 640-page lumbar claim taken through all 6 review passes: page inventory, chronology, 7 flags, missing records, hours and the bill in 3 states.

# Worked example: reviewing a 640-page lumbar claim file
By [Ahmed Jemaa](/about/#author), Co-Founder and CEO of Medrecords AI. Updated 2026-11-12.
**Answer in brief:** this synthetic lumbar file (synthetic, no real patient) has 640 pages, of which 88 are duplicates and 4 belong to another patient, leaving 548 to review. At 50 pages an hour plus 2 MRI studies, the review takes about 11.3 hours and turns up 7 flags, including a 2019 lumbar MRI, 2 versions of the mechanism and a missing operative note. Washington would pay $187.96 for the reading, California $1,044.00 and Colorado $4,474.88.
**Limits:** Not legal or billing advice. Rules and fees are quoted as read on 2026-11-19 from each state's official code or workers' compensation agency, cover only the states listed, and change every year; verify the current text there before you bill or sign, and ask counsel about your case.
## The referral
A 46-year-old warehouse worker reports a low back injury at work on 2024-02-10. The claim accepts a lumbar strain and disputes an L4-5 disc herniation, treated with a microdiscectomy in November 2024. The requester asks 4 questions: is the herniation caused by the work injury; was the surgery reasonable and necessary; has the worker reached maximum medical improvement; and what work can the worker do now. Every name, date and page in this example is invented.
## Pass 2: the page inventory
Before reading a single note, count. The inventory changes every number that follows: hours, flags and the bill.

| Source | Dates covered | Pages | Exact duplicates | Other patient |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employer report and claim forms | 2024-02 | 12 | 0 | 0 |
| Urgent care | 2024-02-11 to 2024-02-25 | 18 | 6 | 0 |
| Primary care | 2018-06 to 2024-09 | 96 | 14 | 4 |
| Chiropractic | 2019-03 to 2019-05 | 44 | 0 | 0 |
| Orthopedic spine | 2024-04 to 2025-01 | 132 | 30 | 0 |
| Imaging center | 2019-04, 2024-03, 2024-04 | 28 | 10 | 0 |
| Pain management | 2024-06 to 2024-12 | 86 | 12 | 0 |
| Physical therapy | 2024-03 to 2024-08 | 138 | 16 | 0 |
| Hospital surgical admission | 2024-11-13 to 2024-11-15 | 70 | 0 | 0 |
| Pharmacy printout | 2023-01 to 2025-01 | 16 | 0 | 0 |
| **Total** |  | **640** | **88** | **4** |

548 pages remain. The 4 other-patient pages go back to the requester with a note, and they stay out of the page count you certify.
## Pass 3: the chronology, excerpt
The full [chronology](/glossary/#chronology) for this file runs to about 90 lines. These 10 carry the questions:

| Date | Source | Entry | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019-03-04 | Chiropractic | Low back pain after moving furniture; treated 14 visits to 2019-05-20 | pp. 212 to 255 |
| 2019-04-18 | Imaging center | Lumbar MRI: mild L4-5 disc bulge, no nerve root contact | p. 402 |
| 2024-02-11 | Urgent care | "Lifting box at work, felt pull in low back." No leg symptoms. Off work 3 days | p. 14 |
| 2024-03-05 | Physical therapy | Evaluation: back pain only; straight leg raise negative both sides | p. 455 |
| 2024-04-02 | Orthopedic spine | "Fell from ladder at work." New left leg pain to the foot; weak left great toe extension | p. 88 |
| 2024-04-12 | Imaging center | Lumbar MRI: left L4-5 extrusion contacting the L5 root | p. 410 |
| 2024-06-15 | Physical therapy | Discharged for missed visits; next visit 2024-08-01 | p. 571 |
| 2024-08-20 | Pharmacy | Oxycodone filled from 2 prescribers in the same week | p. 634 |
| 2024-11-15 | Hospital | Discharge summary: "L4-5 left microdiscectomy on 2024-11-14, see operative note" | p. 301 |
| 2025-01-09 | Orthopedic spine | Leg pain resolved; back pain 3 of 10; light duty recommended | p. 140 |

## Pass 5: the flags

| # | Flag | Pages | Plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Prior lumbar treatment and a 2019 MRI at the same level | 212 to 255, 402 | Ask about back symptoms from 2019 to 2024; compare the 2019 and 2024 images, not only the reports |
| 2 | Mechanism changes from lifting (urgent care) to a ladder fall (orthopedics) | 14, 88 | Take a history before showing any record; ask whether there were 2 events |
| 3 | First leg symptoms 7 weeks after the injury; PT on 2024-03-05 records a negative straight leg raise | 455, 88 | Ask when the leg pain began and what happened just before |
| 4 | Gap in therapy from 2024-06-15 to 2024-08-01 | 571 | Ask the reason; look for any event in the gap |
| 5 | Overlapping opioid prescriptions from 2 prescribers | 634 | Build a medication timeline; note without inferring motive |
| 6 | Operative note cited in the discharge summary but not in the file | 301 | Request it before the exam; the surgery question depends on it |
| 7 | 4 pages for another patient in the primary care records | 61 to 64 | Remove from the count; tell the requester |

Figure 1. The flags on a timeline. The 5-year quiet period between the 2019 care and the 2024 injury is itself a finding worth a sentence.
## Pass 6 and the bill
The close-out produces a records-reviewed list of 10 sources with page ranges, a certified count of 548 pages, a request for the operative note, and an exam plan built from flags 1 to 4. Time: 548 pages at 50 pages an hour is 10.96 hours, plus 2 MRI studies read at 10 minutes each, about 11.3 hours. What that reading is worth:

| Schedule | What counts | Arithmetic | Paid for reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Washington 1129M | 548 unique pages, 400 included | 148 x $1.27 | $187.96 |
| California ML-PRR | 548 pages reviewed, 200 included | 348 x $3.00 | $1,044.00 |
| Colorado | 11.3 hours, 46 units of 15 minutes | 46 x $97.28 | $4,474.88 |
| Texas [designated doctor](/glossary/#designated-doctor) | Bundled | none | $0 beyond the exam fee |

Run the same numbers with your own pace in the [estimator](/review-time-estimator/). The rules behind each line are on the [state rules](/state-rules/) page.
## What this example teaches
- **Count first.** 92 of 640 pages (14%) were duplicates or the wrong patient. Reading them would have cost about 1.8 hours and earned nothing in Washington.
- **The questions live in a handful of pages.** 10 chronology lines carry all 4 referral questions. The other 538 pages confirm the picture or add nothing.
- **The missing record is the most important flag.** Without the operative note, the surgery question cannot be answered from the file. Ask for it before the exam, not in an [addendum](/glossary/#addendum).
- **Old records matter most for [causation](/glossary/#causation).** The 2019 chiropractic notes and MRI sit 5 years before the injury, in a source most requesters would not think to send. Here they were sent; often they are not, which makes "prior records requested" a standard line in the exam plan.
Passes 2 and 3 on a file like this are the part Medrecords AI does: it removes duplicates, lists sources, builds the dated chronology with page cites and flags records that appear to be missing. You verify it, examine and sign. [See how it prepares an IME file](https://medrecords.ai/guides/workers-comp-ime-record-review/?src=imerecordsreview.com).
